Earlier in the week, I watched a preview screening of Josh Radnor’s new film Liberal Arts. It a film about growing up and is filled with a nostalgic longing for the past, for all those things that everybody claims are lost or dying – reading, letter writing, burning a CD and it left me with a longing for my university days when there was such pleasure in receiving a long letter, hand written and heartfelt, from a friend in a different part of the country. None of us – that is me and my school friends – communicates like that any more even though we are still scattered all over the place. We don’t even e-mail any more, just message on Facebook or texts. Of course, it is a sign of how busy we all are. There are easier options now then having to find the time to write a letter but part of me still wishes that we had to do it, that there was no other option but to sit down and ponder what news we had to tell. Of course, I could still do it but it would be a bit pointless. Everyone knows my news anyway – facebook has seen to that – and I know their response to it as well. All in far less time then it would take for a letter to arrive and be read. This is progress, apparently.
Early in the film, Radnor’s character, Jesse, is walking along the street reading a book and I was struck immediately by how this scene would never work with someone walking along with a Kindle.For a start, you would not be able to see what was being read. At least part of the point of reading in public has to do with showing off what you are reading. Not only could you not bear to put this book down but you are showcasing your taste and, possibly, your intellectualism. I know that it irks me that when I read my kindle on the train, no one can tell what I am reading. I always try to see what other people are reading as well. But also, it wouldn’t suggest the same sort of romantic idealism if Jesse was carrying a grey plastic oblong rather than a book with a beautiful cover.
There is a sense of nostalgia at the moment for the loss of something that hasn’t disappeared yet but it seems inevitable that it will. I have seen several articles in the last few weeks about the death of books once everyone has a kindle or the equivalent. And it does seem inevitable. I was never going to have an I-Pod, a kindle or join Facebook and Twitter. Now I have both those things, have joined both those things. I always succumb. Eventually, I guess, books will be like the rows and rows of LP records in my spare bedroom – only present in the houses of people over a certain age.
In some ways, it is strange that so much fuss is being made about the way in which something is read or listened to. Does it matter whether you’re reading from a electronic screen or from a paper page as long as you are reading? Obviously not. I know that some of the sixth formers I taught found it much easier to read from a kindle than from a book. And obviously that pleased me. But this is not a cold logical argument. It is emotional, nostalgic and romantic. It is obviously romantic to take the time to talk about books, to search in second hand book stores for hard to come by editions. It is more romantic to write long handwritten letters rather than a one sentence update on Facebook which someone will then like. And it is far more romantic to hand over a CD you have burned with a handwritten card than to send someone a playlist on Spotify. (Although arguably not as romantic as making a mix tape.) Similarly, when it is my birthday I will still be asking for physical books and CDs. The thought of some sort of electrical exchange seems cold and somehow not real.
Liberal Arts is like a love letter to all these things. All the things that are more time consuming, more difficult but ultimately more meaningful. Reading brings people together in this film and it teaches them how to live their lives. You have to hope that this will still be the case when everyone is reading books from a oblong of grey plastic
2 thoughts on “A nostalgic longing for the past.”
When I got my new (to me) car, which seems recently but was in fact two years ago now, I got rid of all my cassettes and wallowed in nostalgia for all the mix-tapes given to me in school and uni that I’d never get back. There was something special about them, I’d listened to them on and off for years and years, and now they’re gone. CDs while better for many reasons never felt as special as mix-tapes, with their pops and crackles. I downloaded a lot of the individual songs, even put them into playlists that matched the tape, but it was never the same. It got me to thinking about all those letters, and planning to write more, although of course I still haven’t.
I don’t own a kindle and don’t intend to. Although I have the app on my phone which I use sometimes (I’ve owned the phone 20 months and read one and a half books on it, usually in waiting rooms, by contrast I read about 1 “real” book a week or fortnight). For me it’s not so much the uniformity and not being able to see what people are reading. I love books because they have lives outside their readers. I can loan a book I’ve loved on to someone else, pass a book I’m less keen on to someone I think will like it, donate them to charity shops and jumble sales. I get most of my books now second hand, or borrowed from the library, often coming across things I’d never heard of and genres I wouldn’t usually pick up. You get a sense from the folds and creases how often the book’s been read before. As far as I know there’s no such thing, yet, as a second hand kindle book. You can’t pass it on, only recommend it. So I’ll keep to the charity shops and libraries for now, while they last
I quite agree with you. I do find the kindle a bit cold and you don’t get the same emotional attachment to other readers as you do when you read a book. I like to be able to share books I’ve liked as well and this I think is one of the worst things about the kindle.